Compare Red Sift vs. Mailgun

Improve deliverability and boost email ROI with Red Sift OnDMARC

Red Sift OnDMARC simplifies email security with dynamic SPF, MTA-STS & BIMI, minimizing complexity and manual tasks. All-in-one place.

5 star rating
69 reviews
Compare Red Sift vs. Mailgun

Improve deliverability and boost email ROI with Red Sift OnDMARC

Red Sift OnDMARC simplifies email security with dynamic SPF, MTA-STS & BIMI, minimizing complexity and manual tasks. All-in-one place.

5 star rating
69 reviews
The G2 leader for DMARC
Why marketing teams choose Red Sift

How teams approach security is fundamentally changing. The only path forward is to proactively anticipate risk instead of reacting to incidents. 

Easy to use

For organizations reliant on email for customer acquisition, invoicing, and support, Red Sift OnDMARC ensures critical messages are delivered.

Protection from advanced threats

Red Sift simplifies DMARC enforcement, offering a trusted, reliable path to compliance with streamlined management.

Only integrated provider for BIMI

The only integrated solution for BIMI, helping marketing teams boost brand trust and email deliverability with DMARC enforcement and verified logos.

Migrating to Red Sift OnDMARC
Sounds great, but I have a few questions …
Don’t all DMARC providers help me manage email security protocols in one place?

Red Sift OnDMARC consolidates DMARC, SPF, DKIM, MTA-STS, and BIMI into a single platform. Other email security management solutions, such as Mailgun, often stop at DMARC, SPF and DKIM.

Am I going to have to change my DNS?

With Red Sift OnDMARC you can change your DNS once and never touch it again. We have helped many Mailgun customers make the change before migrations so there is no risk of downgrading from full enforcement during the transition.

What about threats that can bypass DMARC?

By proactively monitoring DNS (the foundation that DMARC relies on) for forgotten domains and subdomains, we prevent email security attacks that bypass DMARC – like SubdoMailing. Red Sift is the only provider on the market that can offer this protection.

I don't have time for the manual work of DMARC.

Unlike other DMARC providers, OnDMARC’s LLM-powered assistant leverages AI to cut down manual tasks and provide security teams with immediate, actionable insights. Real-time alerts quickly highlight misconfigurations, authentication issues, or unusual activity, allowing your team to respond instantly.

Isn’t switching really hard?

Switching from Mailgun to Red Sift for DMARC is designed to be seamless. Our Customer Success team will guide you step-by-step, from initial configuration to ongoing adjustments. This dedicated approach ensures a smooth and efficient adoption of DMARC, SPF, DKIM, BIMI and MTA-STS, without disrupting your email security or deliverability.

RED SIFT OnDMARC

Red Sift OnDMARC streamlines email security for marketing teams by eliminating manual work, improving deliverability, and protecting your brand with AI-driven automation.

Red Sift OnDMARC
Mailgun free reporting

DMARC, SPF, DKIM management

Automated onboarding and continuous monitoring improve your sender reputation and increase the likelihood that your emails land in inboxes.

Manual analysis and policy adjustments without built-in automation.

MTA-STS & BIMI integration

Integrated within the platform for full email security stack and brand enhancement.

Siloed setup and maintenance for full email security and brand visibility.

Dynamic SPF

Unique feature automating DNS record updates to reduce complexity and errors to improve deliverability.

Provides standard SPF record insights but requires manual updates and complex management.

Interface and usability

Intuitive, simple UI, highly suitable for non-technical users and scalable for enterprises.

Manual analysis and policy changes, which may require technical expertise.

Brand protection features

Extended protection beyond DMARC compliance to defend against brand impersonation, lookalike domain threats, and minimizing phishing attacks.

Without additional protection against brand impersonation, lookalike domains, or advanced phishing threats.

Domain/Subdomain discovery

Automated discovery and configuration for all associated domains and subdomains.

Manual tracking and setup of domains and subdomains.

Support

Customer success team available via email and chat. Dedicated account manager included in Enterprise tier.

Check your DMARC status

Basic support resources, but direct customer success assistance and dedicated account management are not included.

Red Sift OnDMARC
Mailgun free reporting

DMARC, SPF, DKIM management

Automated onboarding and continuous monitoring improve your sender reputation and increase the likelihood that your emails land in inboxes.

Manual analysis and policy adjustments without built-in automation.

MTA-STS & BIMI integration

Integrated within the platform for full email security stack and brand enhancement.

Siloed setup and maintenance for full email security and brand visibility.

Dynamic SPF

Unique feature automating DNS record updates to reduce complexity and errors to improve deliverability.

Provides standard SPF record insights but requires manual updates and complex management.

Interface and usability

Intuitive, simple UI, highly suitable for non-technical users and scalable for enterprises.

Manual analysis and policy changes, which may require technical expertise.

Brand protection features

Extended protection beyond DMARC compliance to defend against brand impersonation, lookalike domain threats, and minimizing phishing attacks.

Without additional protection against brand impersonation, lookalike domains, or advanced phishing threats.

Domain/Subdomain discovery

Automated discovery and configuration for all associated domains and subdomains.

Manual tracking and setup of domains and subdomains.

Support

Customer success team available via email and chat. Dedicated account manager included in Enterprise tier.

Check your DMARC status

Basic support resources, but direct customer success assistance and dedicated account management are not included.

REVIEWS
Over 1,000+ organizations choose Red Sift OnDMARC

Migrating from Agari to Red Sift FAQ

Which should I use: Red Sift OnDMARC or Agari?

Choosing between Red Sift OnDMARC and Agari DMARC Protection depends on your business’s specific needs and challenges.

Red Sift OnDMARC simplifies the management of DMARC, DKIM, SPF, MTA-STS and offers fully hosted BIMI with VMC provisioning. Uniquely, Red Sift OnDMARC bridges the gap between DMARC and DNS by continuously monitoring for misconfigurations and forgotten records in DNS, ensuring that gaps attackers might exploit are closed before they become issues. In addition, its LLM-powered assistant cuts down on manual tasks and gives security teams immediate, actionable insights to address email security issues. 

Agari DMARC Protection, on the other hand, is designed for large enterprises and financial institutions, offering dynamic management of DMARC, SPF, and DKIM and strong alerting capabilities. However, it requires a more complex setup and management, lacks integrated BIMI and hosted MTA-STS, and doesn’t offer DNS protection or an in-built LLM.

How does Red Sift OnDMARC simplify DMARC adoption compared to Agari?

Red Sift OnDMARC streamlines DMARC adoption with an intuitive setup wizard, and the Investigate tool, which enables real-time configuration troubleshooting. This reduces dependency on IT teams and accelerates implementation, with customers often achieving DMARC enforcement within 6-8 weeks. Red Sift’s Dynamic Services enables automate management of DMARC, DKIM, SPF, and MTA-STS without direct DNS access, simplifying updates and avoiding manual errors. 

In contrast, Agari often requires more manual setup and configurations, leading to potential delays and dependencies on IT teams.

Is Red Sift OnDMARC scalable for large enterprises and smaller businesses?

Yes, Red Sift OnDMARC is highly scalable, designed to meet the needs of both SMEs and large enterprises. The platform's flexibility allows it to be tailored to diverse business sizes, offering the same comprehensive security benefits without adding complexity. It scales smoothly while ensuring ease of use for all users.

What kind of support can I expect with Red Sift OnDMARC?

Red Sift offers hands-on, personalized support from a dedicated customer success team available via chat, email, and guided implementation assistance. This ensures smooth onboarding and minimizes misconfiguration risks, unlike some alternatives that may rely solely on general support channels.

Do you have a step-by-step guide for Security and IT teams on the migration process?

Switching from Fortra’s Agari to Red Sift OnDMARC is straightforward. This guide outlines the key steps to ensure a smooth transition, focusing on migrating DMARC, SPF, and DKIM records without impacting email security or deliverability.

See how our intuitive and automated platform simplifies DMARC compliance